Thoughts on a Chocolate Chip Cookie

George McFly once said “You can accomplish anything if you put your mind to it.” Well, Doc Brown may have inspired the sentiment, but it has never been more true for me than with these cookies. They were absolute perfection. The crispy golden brown exterior gave way to a dense, chewy center swirled with layer upon luscious layer of dark chocolate. And the salt! Why aren’t we sprinkling sea salt flakes on everything? These cookies will change your life. Make them immediately.

Is there a better combination than a cold glass of milk and a warm, freshly baked chocolate chip cookie? Oh, you’re still thinking and haven’t come up with anything yet? That’s what I thought. It helps if the cookies are roughly the size of your face, as was the case with these. I seriously haven’t been able to stop thinking about them. They even came up in casual conversations with friends, for example, a gchat with the one and only Ms. Grinch:

Rachel: how did the cookies taste?!?!
me: the cookies were out. of. this. world.
Rachel: did you put the right amount of chocolate in them?
me: those will now be the chocolate chip cookies i make for the rest of my life
they were incredbile
i think i might put in more chocolate next time
the disks made for these awesome layers of chocolate all throughout the cookies
and the consistency! they were perfect — crisp on the outside and dense and chewy on the inside
Rachel: you are making me hungry
me: i’m pretty much writing the blog post in this gchat box
Rachel: can you just do a screen shot of it?
me: haha, i should

Clearly these cookies leave an indelible mark on any who dare take one soft, chewy bite. I described them to my brother while he was driving and I thought he might run off the road. They are that good. Their deliciousness even translates over the phone.

The dough came together nicely, but the large fancy chocolate disks didn’t incorporate themselves quite the way that chocolate chips do. They kind of stuck out at odd angles and I feared at first that I actually had too much chocolate (there are worse problems to have, I realize this). But they lived up to their hefty price in the end and didn’t show their true worth until the cookies came out of the oven laced with ribbons of melted chocolate. Also, adding cornstarch to the dry ingredients completely negated the need for two different types of flours, which was a bonus. Thanks Caroline!

These chocolate disks do things chocolate chips couldn’t even imagine. In some cases one of the chocolate disks was left exposed on top of a scoop of dough only to turn into a pool of molten chocolate resting in a warm cookie crater.

The chilled dough was a little tough to scoop right out of the fridge. Sadly, my brand new cookie scoop couldn’t even stand up to this uber intense dough. It was a cookie casualty. I ended up using a 1/3 cup measure to scoop and shape the dough and it worked just fine. The sprinkling of sea salt on each mound of dough is really what sealed the deal. Not only does it give the cookies that perfect combination of sweet and savory, but the salt inehrently brings out all the best flavors in the cookies — the molasses notes from the slowly caramelizing brown sugar, the bitter sweetness of the dark chocolate, the floral essence of the vanilla — it’s the whole package, all wrapped up in one ginormous cookie.

These cookies were totally worth the extended refrigeration time required for the dough. Both the flavors and texture benefited from the extra time in the fridge and on top of that, the slowly building anticipation only enhanced the quality of the final product. And by that I mean they were bangin’. Obviously it was difficult not to just start eating the dough right out of the bowl before it even made it into the fridge…which we did anyway. The minute I finished making the dough we pretty much treated it like a bowl of salsa and the over sized chocolate disks like tortilla chips and went to town. So naturally I ended up with an unbalanced ratio of dough to chocolate when it came time to bake. But I found a solution for the leftover scraps! I took one chocolate disk and completely encased it with dough, rolled it into a smooth oval shape, sprinkled it with sea salt, and popped it in the oven. The experiment was a success as it yielded the enigmatically genius inside out cookie pictured above. Even the ubiquitous chocolate chip cookie can end up full of surprises.

About gttebykate

I am an amateur cook and baker who likes to feed her friends and whip up a frenzy in the kitchen. While I adore butter, sugar, and every kind of baked good, I also like to experiment with healthier options and substitutions...sometimes.
This entry was posted in Cookies and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Thoughts on a Chocolate Chip Cookie

  1. janie horn says:

    Kate, where can I get the recipe????

  2. gttebykate says:

    The original recipe is from this New York Times article:
    But I used a modified version from my friend’s food blog:

    They are SO good! You’ve never had a chocolate chip cookie like this, I swear.

  3. Eric says:


    You have achieved what some might think impossible: You have triggered salivation through writing. God speed.

  4. Pingback: My Kind of Sandwich | Good Things to Eat

  5. Pingback: On the twelfth day of Christmas… | Good Things to Eat

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s